Ex-husband has sufficient interest in ex-mother-in-law's estate to challenge Will as a forgery
Randall -v- Randall: Could the Consent Order agreed as to a divorce have been drafted differently to protect against a subsequent probate dispute?
The background is that when the husband and wife divorced they agreed that any inheritance received by the wife from her mother’s estate, which exceeded £100,000, would be shared with the husband. When the wife's mother died she left the wife £100,000 and she left the wife's children £150,000. The (ex)husband sought to challenge the validity of the Will on the basis it was a forgery, alleging that it had not been validly executed in accordance with section 9 of the Wills Act 1937. At first instance the judge held that the husband did not have sufficient interest to challenge the validity of the Will. The husband appealed.
The wife maintained that only those who were able to assert a right to administer the estate (not the husband) could bring a contentious probate claim. Since the husband was not named as an executor under the Will, he was not entitled to a share in the estate and was not a creditor of the estate he did not have a sufficient interest to bring the claim.
The court disagreed with the wife and allowed the appeal. The right to bring a claim was a procedural issue. The husband's position was not similar to a creditor of the estate. A creditor did not have sufficient interest to bring a probate claim. The Lord Justices were in agreement that the husband should be allowed to bring a claim to challenge the validity of the Will so as to ensure the case is dealt with justly. Significantly, if unable to challenge the Will, the husband would have no other route. Lord Dyson said ‘He is not a mere busybody. He has a real interest in challenging the validity of the Will.’
So, we are yet to learn if the Will was a forgery.
Tees is here to help
We have many specialist lawyers who are based in:
Cambridgeshire: Cambridge
Essex: Brentwood, Chelmsford, and Saffron Walden
Hertfordshire: Bishop's Stortford and Royston
But we can help you wherever you are in England and Wales.
Chat to the Author, Sara Stabler
Senior Associate, Dispute Resolution and Litigation, Cambridge office
Meet Sara- Areas of expertise
- Accreditations
- Testimonials
Legal 500 UK 2024
East Anglia, Cambridge
Sara Stabler is a remarkably thorough and careful solicitor, but also very pragmatic and down to earth.
Legal 500 UK 2024
East Anglia, Cambridge
Sara Stabler is the kind of litigator you want on your side. She specialises in contested probate matters, which, as all lawyers know, are some of the most difficult to resolve. Sara’s approach is unwaveringly client-focused but tempered with a sense of reality and good humour. Her legal acumen is outstanding, and I always immensely enjoy working with her.
Legal 500 UK 2022
Cambridge
Sara Stabler – I was impressed by her approach and knowledge. Someone who knows what they are doing in this area. Approachable, sensible and very client-friendly. I would be happy to recommend clients to her and know they were in good hands.
Legal 500 UK 2022
Sara Stabler is always actively involved and brings a pragmatic and hands-on approach. She is extremely business minded and responsive.
Legal 500 UK 2024
'Sara Stabler is a remarkably thorough and careful solicitor, but also very pragmatic and down to earth'
Legal 500 UK 2023
'Sara Stabler and her team are consistently really strong performers. They have excellent work and it is clear that their clients receive really good service'